Free content is a proof of concept. Not a charity.
👋 Welcome back to Content to Commas, your weekly playbook for turning content into authority, consistency, and growth.
A few days ago I was on a call with an entrepreneur restructuring everything. Podcast. Digital products. Sponsorships.
The whole business.
Halfway through, she asked me …
"How do I know when to charge for something? What should I give for free vs charge for?"
I'd been asked versions of that question before. But sitting with it that day, I realized I've never actually written down how I decide. I just do it.
So I went home and mapped it out.
This issue is about drawing the line between free and paid so your content feeds your business.
📌 In this issue:
The Free/Paid Line: 3 rules I use to decide what to charge for
3 pricing myths that keep creators broke
One question that ends the "should I charge?" debate forever
Let’s get to work.
— Brandon
a message from our friends @ Teachable
The re-learning never stops.
Ten years in social media taught me one thing. The platform always changes. The algorithm always shifts. The best practice you built your reputation on has an expiration date.
That's not a social media problem anymore. That's every industry now.
AI is moving on the same cycle. What worked six months ago is already being replaced. And 66% of workers using AI right now got zero formal training from their employer.
They're just expected to figure it out.
The people who win in that environment aren't the most experienced. They're the most willing to re-learn.
Teachable's 2026 Creator Trend Report surveyed 355 paying learners on exactly this shift — how AI is changing the way people discover and buy education, what keeps students engaged, and what it actually takes to build a knowledge business.
If you're building anything in this space, this is worth your time.
🙋♂ Let me tell you what I give away for free…
This newsletter. Most of my social content. Co-branded Webinars. A handful of digital products.
I share knowledge freely. Probably more than my accountant would recommend.
Why? two reasons…
One, I genuinely like helping people. I'm only where I am because someone opened a door for me, and once I was in, I made it my job to open doors for other people. That's the truth.
Two, it's strategic. Free content is the best proof of paid content. If what I give you for free is already useful, the thing I charge for has to be better by default. That's my whole bet.
If your free stuff is forgettable, your paid stuff is a gamble.
But free without a line is just a hobby and that's where a lot of creators get stuck. They give away everything, then wonder why no one buys anything.
So here's how I actually draw the line 👇
🎯 Think like a business, not a creator.
Content creators think in posts. (video, podcast, carousel)
Businesses think in outcomes. (leads, churn, revenue)
A content creator asks, "What should I post about?"
A business asks, "What am I selling, and how does this piece of content move someone closer to buying it?"
If you don't know what you're selling, everything feels like it should be free, because everything's just content.
When you know what you're selling, the line draws itself.
The simplest way to think about it: free builds trust, paid delivers transformation.
… now let me get specific about what that actually looks like
🪜 The Free to Paid Pricing Ladder
Everything you sell falls into one of three buckets: done-by-them, done-with-you, or done-for-you.
Where you draw the line between free and paid lives right in the middle.
1. Done-by-them = Free.
You're teaching someone what to do and leaving them to go do it.
Newsletters. LinkedIn posts. Podcast episodes. Free workshops. A public breakdown of a framework.
The reader walks away smarter. They still have to go build the thing themselves but that's the point.
If someone can watch you, listen to you, or read you and walk away fully enabled, that's free.
2. Done-with-you = Mid-tier paid.
This is where you stop being a publisher and start being a partner. You're in the work with them.
Coaching, group programs, small cohorts, office hours, paid communities, paid workshops with live Q&A.
The transformation comes from you guiding their specific situation. Not from general information.
People pay for done-with-you when they've consumed your free content, applied it, and gotten stuck on their own variables.
3. Done-for-you = Premium paid.
You're not teaching anymore. You're doing. You take the thing off their plate.
Consulting retainers. Agency work. Fractional roles. Custom builds. Full audits with implementation.
The buyer isn't paying for your knowledge. They're paying to not have to become you.
This is the highest ticket and the most protected.
You should not be doing done-for-you work for free, ever. Not for exposure. Not for "portfolio."
If you're doing the work, you get paid for the work.
⚡ Your Move This Week
Write down everything you currently offer. Every post, workshop, freebie, call, template, service.
Put each one into a bucket: done-by-them, done-with-you, or done-for-you.
Find the thing that's sitting in the wrong bucket. The done-with-you work you've been giving away. The done-for-you work you quoted at coffee prices.
Move it. Price it.
Was this issue useful?
📌 ICYMI…
Each week, I share simple tips on branding, making money, growth strategies, and useful tools that you might have missed. You can catch up in just a few minutes.
Posts You May Have Missed…
These posts did numbers for a reason. Worth a reread.
🔍 How to Actually Show Up in AI Search: A friend texted me that her Notion template showed up as a recommendation in ChatGPT. In two years, you'll want AI suggesting your product, service, or business. Here's how to get there now → See the play
🛤️ The Content Path: How I think about the content funnel and, more importantly, the role each piece plays so nothing you publish is wasted → Walk the path
🤫 The Secret LinkedIn Feature I Use Every Week: How I use it to grow my newsletter and keep my inbox from running my life → Steal the move
📘 My Personal LinkedIn Content Playbook: The exact system I use to show up, stay consistent, and turn posts into pipeline. Free to download → Grab the playbook
💰 The Revenue Offline Test: The simple check I run to figure out what's actually responsible for the money coming in (and what's just vibes) → Run the test
Community Favorites…
Handpicked for where you are right now.
🪂 The Involuntary Entrepreneur: A playbook for the people who didn't choose this life but got pushed into it. Layoff, restructure, end of contract. If this is you (or someone you know), start here → Open the playbook
🏛️ Why You Need Pillar Content: The pieces that hold your whole content strategy up. Without them, everything you post is floating → See the blueprint
🏃 How to Get Your Content in Shape: Treat your content like a muscle. Plan, reps, and recovery. The workout plan for creators who keep falling off → Start the program
💰 Monetization 101 (Myths & Moves): The stories keeping you broke and the moves that actually put money in the bank → Make the move
🚀 My 5 Personal Branding Principles: The rules I built my brand on, pulled from a decade of leading content at places like Ralph Lauren, Squarespace, and Kickstarter → Steal the principles
Tools I Love…
The stack I keep coming back to in my own business.
🧠 Granola: The best AI meeting notetaker I’ve used. No bots joining calls. No interruptions. Just clean notes → Try Granola
📧 Beehiiv: Newsletters plus websites, podcast hosting, and link-in-bio. Use this exclusive link for 20% off 3 months → Launch a Beehiiv
🎙️ Wispr Flow: The number one tool I use daily. Voice-to-text that actually works, writes 10x faster than typing, and sounds like me. Try it free for a month → Try Wispr Flow
🤖 Stanley: My LinkedIn AI content coach. After talking with the team, I got you 7 days free (the highest they offer). It learns your tone and tells you exactly what's clicking → Try Stanley free for 7 days
⚙️ Relay.app: How I build AI agents without writing a single line of code. If you want to automate your content workflow, start here → Try it free
💬 ManyChat: The tool I trust for social media automations. Comments, DMs, lead capture. It runs in the background so you don't have to → Build the flow
🎨 Gamma: The fastest way to build a presentation with AI. Clean output, no design skills needed → Try Gamma
📅 Cal.com: I fired Calendly. This is what I use now. Way more affordable, does everything you need → Make the switch
🏦 Mercury: Business banking that stays clean. Deposit $10K in 90 days and get $250 → Open an account
Free Resources For You…
📷 Content Kit: The exact equipment to build dynamic content → Explore more
🧰 Ultimate Creatorpreneur Toolkit: 70+ tools I used to build a six-figure business, with exclusive discounts → Grab the toolkit
🪝 250 Proven LinkedIn Hooks: Copy, tweak, grow your brand faster → Get the hooks
🤝 How to Land a Brand Deal: Zero-fluff guide to inbound and outreach that works → Learn the playbook

Brandon Smithwrick, Creator of Content to Commas™
Thanks for reading! Say hi 👋 on LinkedIn
If this newsletter helped you make money, save time, or get unstuck… I want the receipt
Was this newsletter forwarded to you? Subscribe here
Interested in advertising? Get in touch




